Choosing a CCM platform comes down to ten questions, asked in writing of every vendor on the shortlist and answered with a demonstration on your own documents. Features matter less than they seem, because most enterprise platforms can produce a good letter. What separates them is how they behave after go-live:
- Who can change content, and how quickly?
- Will you run the platform yourself, or buy it as a managed service?
- Which channels does one template reach?
- How does data flow from your source systems to the output channels, including print?
- Can it handle your peak runs?
- Can it prove what each customer received and who approved it?
- Where is the data processed, and what security evidence is there?
- How is the price built up?
- How do your existing templates get onto it?
- How do you leave again?
Each question below comes with what a good answer looks like.
Who can change content, and how quickly?
Ask the vendor to show a real change: a clause in a policy letter that legal wants reworded. Watch who makes it and how many steps it takes.
The old way is that every edit goes through IT, joins a release, and reaches customers weeks later. Modern low-code tools let business owners make content changes themselves, inside guardrails that IT sets once: approved content blocks, locked mandatory text, and an approval step before anything goes live.
A good answer: a business owner makes the change in a browser, a second person approves it, and it is in production the same day or the next. If AI helps draft the text, the same approval applies. AI can help draft; a person approves.
Should you run the platform yourself or buy a managed service?
This is the decision that shapes the rest of the checklist, because it decides what your own IT has to staff.
| Activity | Platform you run yourself | Managed service |
|---|---|---|
| Hosting, upgrades and monitoring | IT | Provider |
| Integrations with source systems | IT | Provider, per your instructions |
| Content changes | Business owners | Business owners |
| Approval of what customers receive | You | You |
| Incident handling | IT | Both, with the provider able to fix remotely |
Running it yourself gives full control and needs IT capacity for a system that is not your core product. A managed service moves the technical work to the provider while the content, the approvals and the responsibility stay with you. Eclipse is one example of the managed route, under the name CCMaaS. That stands for CCM as a service: the provider runs the platform, and you keep the content and the approvals. Who owns, approves and runs what is worked out in more detail in our post on the customer communication operating model.
A good answer from any vendor: a clear list of what they do, what you do, and what that costs, for the model you are buying.
Which channels does one template reach?
Customers receive the same message on paper, by email, by SMS, in a portal and through WhatsApp. In the Netherlands, government bodies also send digital post through the MijnOverheid Berichtenbox, which only organisations connected to MijnOverheid can use.
A good answer: one template and one set of business rules produce every channel, so a wording change is made once. Ask which channels are live for other customers today and which are on a roadmap.
How does data flow from your source systems to the output channels?
Customer data sits in several systems: policy administration, core banking, billing, CRM or case management. One letter often needs data from more than one of them, and every output channel, print included, expects its own format. Questions to ask:
- Does the platform bring data from different source systems together in one canonical data model, so every template works from the same set of data?
- What happens when two sources conflict, or a field is missing? Does the run stop, and who is notified?
- How does it merge records from several sources, and how can you check that the merge was right?
- How does data move through the platform, and is it encrypted in transit and at rest?
- How are the output channels connected, including your print partner, and who sees whether each hand-over succeeded?
A good answer: one data model for all templates, written rules for conflicts and gaps with an alert to a named person before anything goes out, encryption along the whole route, and tested connections to every channel and the print partner, with a report of each hand-over.
Key takeaway: A letter is only as correct as the data behind it. Ask to see what the platform does with conflicting or missing data before anything reaches a customer.
Can it handle your peak runs?
Annual statements, indexation letters and tax documents arrive in peaks, which is where scalable CCM earns its keep. Ask the vendor to describe a run at your own peak volume, what happens if it fails halfway, and how capacity grows. Does the platform scale up and down automatically, or does someone have to request extra servers or storage and wait for them?
A good answer: capacity follows the load without a request or a wait and drops back afterwards. The run restarts from the point of failure without duplicates, and you are told what was produced and what was not.
Can it prove what each customer received and who approved it?
Supervisors and auditors ask for one customer’s communication on one date: what was sent, which template version produced it, who approved that version, and whether it was delivered. Our post on the customer communication audit trail sets out what regulators expect here.
A good answer: the platform records all four at production time, for every channel, and you retrieve them for one customer in minutes. A PDF archive alone covers only the first.
Where is the data processed, and what security evidence is there?
Ask for the region where customer data is processed and stored, who at the provider can access it, and which subprocessors are involved. EU rules allow transfers outside the EEA only with special safeguards so that the protection travels with the data. DORA does not impose data localisation, but it does expect a financial entity to know where its outsourced functions are provided and where data is processed.
A good answer: an EU region named in the contract, a current ISO 27001 certificate whose scope covers the service you are buying, and an assurance report such as ISAE 3402 or a SOC 2 Type II report if your auditor asks for one.
How is the price built up?
CCM prices usually have three parts: a licence or subscription, an implementation estimated as hours times a rate, and running costs that are fixed or move with volume. How those parts balance depends on the model:
- On premise: an upfront investment in licences, infrastructure and implementation, then the cost of your own IT to run and upgrade it.
- CCM as a service: a smaller upfront investment, mostly implementation, and an operational cost over the contract that covers hosting, upgrades and monitoring.
A good answer: a price you can project over the contract term at your own volumes, including peaks, with every trigger for a change written down. Ask whether the price follows what you actually use, or whether you pay for capacity sized for the peak that sits idle the rest of the year. Ask too what is included in running: upgrades, monitoring, archive and support hours.
How do your existing templates get onto it?
In most selections an existing platform is being replaced. Ask the vendor how they inventory your current templates, how they convert them, and how they prove the new output matches the old. The template count is also where migration estimates most often go wrong.
A good answer: an inventory first, unused templates retired before conversion, and every document family tested side by side on real data before it goes live. Experienced help on the inventory is what makes a faster timeline possible.
How do you leave again?
The best time to agree an exit is before signing. Ask in what format your templates, business rules, content blocks, archive and audit records leave the platform, and how long the provider supports a transition.
Ask too whether your templates could move to another platform at all. Templates built on a widely used composition engine may be easier to move than a proprietary format, so ask which export format they use and whether another platform can read it.
Regulation now backs this up. The EU Data Act has applied since 12 September 2025, requires providers of cloud and software services to remove obstacles to switching, and removes switching charges entirely from 12 January 2027. For financial entities, DORA requires exit strategies for ICT services that support critical or important functions, with a transition period in the contract.
A good answer: export formats named in the contract, a transition period with the provider’s support, and archive access for the full retention period after the contract ends.
Key takeaway: Templates, rules and archive should be able to leave in a format another platform can use. Getting that in writing costs little before signing and a lot after.
How to use the checklist
- Send the ten questions in writing to every vendor on the shortlist.
- Ask each one to demonstrate the content change and the audit trail question on one of your own documents.
- Score the answers yourself, against what your organisation needs, before price enters the discussion.
The written answers then become part of the contract.
Frequently asked questions
Who should be involved in choosing a CCM platform?
The business owners of the main document families, IT, compliance and procurement. Business owners judge content changes and approvals, IT the data flow and integrations, compliance the audit trail. One person owns the final decision.
What should the demonstration on our own documents include?
One of your more complex existing documents, a content change made and approved by a business owner, and the retrieval of what one customer received on one date. Add a test file with a missing or conflicting field to see how the platform reports it.
How many vendors belong on the shortlist?
Few enough to run a demonstration on your own documents with each, in practice three or four. A longer list usually gets a lighter test and answers that are harder to compare.
What is the difference between a CCM platform and a CRM or marketing tool?
A CCM platform produces regulated, personalised documents and messages across channels from governed templates. CRM manages the customer relationship, and marketing automation runs campaigns. See CCM, CRM and marketing automation: who does what?
Related: The evolution of CCM to CXM: from documents to experiences
If you are building a shortlist and want a second view on the answers you get back, we are happy to go through them with you.
